TL;DR: Skip the trial-and-error. The fastest way to get value from Subitem Automations is to set up two specific recipes — they're used by more than a third of all accounts and they take five minutes total. Once these work, the rest of the app makes more sense.
The two recipes that matter most
Across 25,000+ installs, the same two recipes top the usage charts every month — by a huge margin. They're the "default first automations" most teams set up and never turn off:
Sync parent values to subitems on creation — used by 21% of accounts
Sync parent values to subitems on every change — used by 16% of accounts
Together: ~37% of all subitem automation usage. If you do nothing else this week, set these two up.
Which one do you need?
Your situation
Recipe to start with
"New subitems should inherit the parent's owner / priority / due date — but if the parent changes later, existing subitems should stay as they were."
Recipe 1 only
"Whenever the parent's status / owner / priority changes, every subitem should update too — keep them in lockstep forever."
Recipe 2 only
"Both — new subitems should inherit, AND existing subitems should stay in sync."
Both (they don't conflict)
Before you start
The same column type on both parent and subitem (Status → Status, Date → Date, etc.)
Column names don't need to match — you map them in the automation
Read-only columns (Mirror, Formula, Last updated) can't be the destination
Recipe 1 — Sync parent values to subitems on creation
Recipe:"When subitem is created, set value of its column to match value of column in parent."
What it does: The moment a new subitem appears, it inherits the parent's chosen column value. Existing subitems are not touched.
Best for: giving every new subitem a sensible default (Owner, Priority, Due Date) without requiring users to fill in the same value over and over.